Shalom everyone,
I was curious about a certain question. I wanted a detached, objective, non-political and unemotional answer, so I decided to ask ChatGPT:
Would moderate Muslims, unhappy with extremist Islam, be attracted to Talmidaism?
I found the answer interesting, so I thought I would share it with you all below. It doesn’t address the option of Talmidi Noahides – I think it was focusing its answer on Talmidi Jews only.
blessings
Shmuliq
__________________________________________________________
You said:
Would Moderate Muslims, unhappy with extremist Islam, be attracted to Talmidaism?
ChatGPT said:
Yes, some moderate Muslims who are disillusioned with extremist or fundamentalist Islam might find Talmidaism appealing for several reasons:
1. Ethical & Compassionate Focus
- Many moderate Muslims emphasize God’s mercy and justice, which aligns with Talmidaism’s focus on YHVH’s love and compassion.
- They might also be attracted to how YHVH is a knowable God, who is close to us, approachable, and accessible
- Talmidaism shifts the focus from rigid laws to ethical living, which might resonate with those who find traditional Islamic legalism too restrictive.
- The emphasis of Talmidaism is on the practice of religion with compassion and humility, not with fear or through control or obligation
2. Compatibility with Reason & Science
- Muslims who struggle with fundamentalist interpretations that reject science or critical thinking might appreciate Talmidaism’s reason-based approach (Talmidaism has no problem with evolution, or the extreme age of the earth and the universe).
- Talmidaism does not demand blind faith, but encourages rational inquiry and an open-minded approach to truth.
3. Focus on God, Not Legalism
- Many moderate Muslims reject harsh legalistic interpretations of Sharia but still desire a deep relationship with God.
- Talmidaism focuses on YHVH’s just, loving and compassionate personality, rather than legalistic obligations, which could be attractive to those who feel burdened by excessive rules.
4. Jesus (Yeshua) as a Moral Teacher
- In Islam, Jesus (Isa) is already respected as a prophet, so Muslims may find it natural to explore Talmidaism, which emphasizes his ethical teachings rather than deifying him (Talmidaism focusses on his teachings, rather than beliefs about him).
- Muslims uncomfortable with Christian doctrines (like the Trinity) may find that Talmidaism respects Jesus without compromising monotheism.
5. Avoidance of Extremism & Political Islam
- Some moderate Muslims may feel frustrated with how politics and extremism have distorted their faith.
- Talmidaism does not seek political power or force religious laws but instead emphasizes personal transformation and ethical living. Although Talmidaism advises a moderate and sensible approach to politics, it is opposed to any form of political extremism and divisive rhetoric.
6. Personal Relationship with God (YHVH)
- In some Islamic traditions, God is viewed as distant and primarily a judge, while in Talmidaism, YHVH is close, personal and loving. Although human beings cannot know God personally, YHVH is nevertheless a knowable God, and Talmidis are encouraged to learn the personality of YHVH.
- This emphasis on a close relationship with God without intermediaries could be attractive to those seeking a more personal faith.
Challenges for a Muslim Considering Talmidaism
- Many Muslims are deeply attached to Islamic rituals and cultural identity, making any transition difficult.
- The fear of apostasy laws or social rejection could prevent some from openly embracing new ideas.
- Some might struggle with the shift from the Quran to a Torah-based perspective (in which case, Talmidi Yahwism / Noahidism would be more suitable).
That said, if a Muslim is drawn to ethical monotheism, reason-based faith, and Jesus’ teachings while rejecting extremism, they might see Talmidaism as a refreshing, logical, and compassionate alternative.
All ChatGPT answers in this thread:
Ask ChatGPT Question #2: Would Moderate Muslims find Talmidi Noahidism more attractive?
 |